Generational Goodwill Is Running Out
Young Americans are losing patience with their elders. Will retirees take note?
Not long ago, an elderly family member sent me an image of a young Muslim boy laid out on the dirt in the middle of a crowd. He’d been caught stealing food, the caption said, and his entire town had gathered to watch his dad crush his arm with a pickup truck.
It was a disturbing picture – not really something I expected to see during lunch. The boy appeared to be screaming in pain.
But I immediately noticed something about the bystanders. They were too calm. And some of them were, it seemed to me, tourists. So I Googled the episode. It was part of a magic trick, the town gathered for some entertainment. The shtick happened in urban Cairo near the pyramids, amidst hundreds of Western tourists. The boy was unharmed, and even seemed to enjoy the experience.
The person who sent it to me did so with the intention of changing my political views, convinced that this boy was being tortured. “VOTE TRUMP” was written below the image.
Now, I don’t think my experience here is unique. Most of us with a parent or grandparent on Facebook watch some version of this play out every day. The soldier who “never got a single birthday card,” the 92-year-old who carved a life-size church out of a watermelon, the name “Jesus” rendered in shrimp – Facebook is full of these AI-generated posts, all of them fake. But take a peek at the comment sections, and you’re all but certain to meet the same massive crowd of actual, real people – a chorus of senior citizens, uber-patriotic and terminally-online, almost none of them aware that the image isn’t real.
It’s precisely because this is so common that it’s worth talking about. Sure, it’s funny for a minute. Then it’s sad – what must these people’s lives be like?
But a few minutes more, and the anger sets in.
Because this isn’t just a meme about grandma. In 2019, researchers at NYU and Princeton found that Facebook users over 65 shared almost seven times as much content from fake-news sites as users 18 to 29, even after accounting for income level, education, and political party. And AI, of course, has only worsened this problem. Older people are far more likely than anyone else to believe AI-generated content is real, and Facebook’s algorithm loves to feed them more. AI spam pages are racking up millions of views every week, many of them fronts for scams.
If you’ve ever taken over an elderly parent’s or grandparent’s phone, you know the problem isn’t that they can’t use the internet. It’s that they believe it, all whilst being the country’s most politically engaged demographic.
Earlier this month, America’s young people made themselves heard. Exit polls around the country showed that young people broke for Democrats at almost unprecedented levels. Among voters under 45, 65% voted for Democrats. Among Gen Z (voters under 30), the difference was even starker – in Texas, for example, Senator-elect James Talarico won this demographic by a whopping 60 points. Overall, Democrats nationwide flipped seven Republican Senate seats and took both chambers of Congress – one of the sharpest midterm rebukes in memory. Trump wasn’t on the ballot, of course, but about four-in-ten voters told the AP Voter Poll they voted to oppose him.
Americans 65 and up were the one age group Republicans still carried, and they made up more than a third of everyone who voted. Voters under 30? Just one in ten.
That one number (who actually shows up to vote) is the whole story of American politics, and it has, for two decades now, reliably favored the elderly. This is just how things have been.
But things are changing.
Americans over 70 now hold about 31 percent of America’s household wealth – a record, up from 19 percent in 1989. Baby boomers, roughly one-fifth of the population, sit on more than $85 trillion. Millennials, a group about the same size (I’m one of them), hold about $18 trillion. Meanwhile, younger Americans are more pessimistic about their job prospects than they’ve been in years. Last spring, Gallup reported that the gap between how young and old Americans see the job market is wider in the US than in any of the 141 countries it surveys.
And now, hanging over all of this, is a serious deadline. Last June, Social Security’s trustees projected that its retirement trust fund will run out in late 2032. After that, incoming payroll taxes will cover only about 78 percent of promised benefits. Unless Congress figures this out, benefits will drop about 22 percent immediately.
So Congress will do something. The only question is who pays.
Conventional wisdom says the answer is obvious: not seniors. They vote, and they vote hard. When Congress last overhauled Social Security (1983), most of the pain landed on young workers – higher payroll taxes and a later retirement age. Common sense dictates that if you touch current benefits, you lose your seat. No politician forgets that.
But come 2032, I wouldn’t be so sure it still holds.
Fact is, while Social Security has been reliably protected by voters, enough young people vote that the system depends, too, on goodwill – the shared sense that grandma and grandpa earned their benefits and need them. Indeed, many seniors live on these checks alone and are unable to work. A 22 percent cut would be devastating for millions of people.
Nobody wants that for anyone.
But goodwill, of course, doesn’t come built-in. It has to be earned, and right now it’s running low. When young Americans look at their elders today, a lot of them see something different: the wealthiest generation in history, sitting on houses they’ll never afford, flooding social feeds with asinine fabricated nonsense, and voting for the party everyone else just rejected. As far back as 2019, the Harvard Youth Poll found most young Americans didn’t believe baby boomers cared about people like them. I can’t think of much since that would’ve changed their minds.
Think back to that image. The person who sent it to me wasn’t trying to deceive me. They’d been deceived first. But they were ready to believe a man crushed his own son’s arm because a stranger on the internet said so, and they wanted that belief to influence my vote. Now multiply that experience by 50 million inboxes, and one begins to understand why so many young Americans feel like their country is being governed by boomer-slop Facebook feeds.
That frustration, of course, can curdle into something ugly. It’s arguably part of what’s behind student riots in France – anger about high unemployment and a pension system that only ever adjusts in favor of retirees, who are already comfortable. But resentment and riots rarely create lasting solutions. A fight between generations probably won’t end well for anyone. What’s needed, I think, is a little self-awareness from the ones holding most of the cards, before time runs out.
Goodwill is a delicate thing. When it’s working, it’s easy to take for granted; when it’s gone, it’s hard to earn back. In 2032, when Congress decides who absorbs the Social Security shortfall, it will matter a great deal whether young voters, who voted earlier this month with more unity than ever before, still see their elders as vulnerable family worth protecting, or just as a self-interested bloc of gullible “boomers” who traffic in AI slop and care only about themselves.
By the time 2032 comes around, there may not be enough goodwill left.